While Bret is visiting Matt’s empty room, we see a bottle of Hawaiian Surfrider suntan lotion on the missing boy’s bedside table.

It’s a vintage product by a brand that has been off the market for decades. According to the description of the picture above on the website of History For Hire, a prop house located in North Hollywood, “Surfrider, back row left, was a product made in Hawaii and in addition to suntanning lotion expanded their line in other men’s products like cologne.”

As a matter of fact, Hawaiian Surfrider after-shave lotion and men’s cologne sets from the 1960s can still be found online for sale.